I was looking for Kaiju movies when I came across "Monster Island" on Prime.
The title conjured up visions of the old Godzilla movies and a tropical island that was sort of a retirement resort for Kaiju. This is not one of those movies. Like many a SyFy movie, it makes use of a well known screen name for some star power. In this case, Eric Roberts gets the privilege of being the draw alongside the monsters. His character, General Horne, however, is criminally underused. Relegated, as the name stars in small productions often are, to a single set and phone call interaction with the main cast. I honestly did the same thing with Debbie Rochon in "Alien Vengeance" 1 & 2, so that I could get her into both movies with just one visit to Florida, where they were shot back in 2010.
Aside from only letting Horne shout into the phone most of the time, I thought it was odd that he was a GENERAL in the Navy. (Or Coast Guard, but it looked like a naval uniform to me. Military experts feel free to clear this up in the comments.
Alright, enough about the wasted talents of Eric Roberts in the movie, Let's get to what the movieis really about. The monsters!
The word "Kaiju" is thrown around plenty and it applies in the broadest sense of "giant monsters", but fans of the traditional Kaiju movies will likely be disappointed. The creature designs are cool enough and they have some neat powers, even some backstory, but no personality. There is plenty of build up about the main monster before we even hear about the second, which she will fight. This kind of tension building is common in giant monster movies, but I would have preferred a parallel development of the two creatures. As it stands you feel like you're watching a serial more than a feature. Each segment playing out as a story and leading to the next rather than developing as one cohesive story.
The "Pacific Rim" movies have likely made the CG type creations seen here more acceptable as Kaiju and the first creature's design is simple, but effective as a sea monster. Her adversary, however, is a stiff looking lump of a hero. He barely seems to move during a particularly anticlimactic engagement with his nemesis. Considering this a fight for the fate of humanity, you'd think they would dedicate some time to it, but don't go to the bathroom or you'll miss it. And it's paced like a stop motion fight I did. I get it. Animating monster fights is hard work, but this a movie with "Monster" in the title. We need some monster action.
There is a great portion of the movie where the main cast is stranded on the gigantic monster in a small submersible, and honestly, with a low budget, I would have made the entire movie about them trying to stop it from there while an unsuspecting world was waiting for the thing to hit land. But, just as I was beginning to enjoy the suspense and possibilities of this concept, the story moves past it.
Really what "Monster Island" is in the end is a not bad adventure film with monsters in it. Somewhere between the fun of "Tremors" and the epic monster on monster action of the Godzilla series sits the not as good as either, "Monster Island".
Would I recommend it? Well, if you're like me, can't get enough of monster movies, have seen most of the classics and old not so classics and can catch this one for free, then sure, give it a look to pass the time. It's not bad. It's also not a "must see" monster flick.
The title conjured up visions of the old Godzilla movies and a tropical island that was sort of a retirement resort for Kaiju. This is not one of those movies. Like many a SyFy movie, it makes use of a well known screen name for some star power. In this case, Eric Roberts gets the privilege of being the draw alongside the monsters. His character, General Horne, however, is criminally underused. Relegated, as the name stars in small productions often are, to a single set and phone call interaction with the main cast. I honestly did the same thing with Debbie Rochon in "Alien Vengeance" 1 & 2, so that I could get her into both movies with just one visit to Florida, where they were shot back in 2010.
Aside from only letting Horne shout into the phone most of the time, I thought it was odd that he was a GENERAL in the Navy. (Or Coast Guard, but it looked like a naval uniform to me. Military experts feel free to clear this up in the comments.
Alright, enough about the wasted talents of Eric Roberts in the movie, Let's get to what the movieis really about. The monsters!
The word "Kaiju" is thrown around plenty and it applies in the broadest sense of "giant monsters", but fans of the traditional Kaiju movies will likely be disappointed. The creature designs are cool enough and they have some neat powers, even some backstory, but no personality. There is plenty of build up about the main monster before we even hear about the second, which she will fight. This kind of tension building is common in giant monster movies, but I would have preferred a parallel development of the two creatures. As it stands you feel like you're watching a serial more than a feature. Each segment playing out as a story and leading to the next rather than developing as one cohesive story.
The "Pacific Rim" movies have likely made the CG type creations seen here more acceptable as Kaiju and the first creature's design is simple, but effective as a sea monster. Her adversary, however, is a stiff looking lump of a hero. He barely seems to move during a particularly anticlimactic engagement with his nemesis. Considering this a fight for the fate of humanity, you'd think they would dedicate some time to it, but don't go to the bathroom or you'll miss it. And it's paced like a stop motion fight I did. I get it. Animating monster fights is hard work, but this a movie with "Monster" in the title. We need some monster action.
There is a great portion of the movie where the main cast is stranded on the gigantic monster in a small submersible, and honestly, with a low budget, I would have made the entire movie about them trying to stop it from there while an unsuspecting world was waiting for the thing to hit land. But, just as I was beginning to enjoy the suspense and possibilities of this concept, the story moves past it.
Really what "Monster Island" is in the end is a not bad adventure film with monsters in it. Somewhere between the fun of "Tremors" and the epic monster on monster action of the Godzilla series sits the not as good as either, "Monster Island".
Would I recommend it? Well, if you're like me, can't get enough of monster movies, have seen most of the classics and old not so classics and can catch this one for free, then sure, give it a look to pass the time. It's not bad. It's also not a "must see" monster flick.
